Skip to main content

Launching BBC television

Published: 18 February 2022

John Logie Baird demonstrated television for the first time in 1926. So why, ten years later, was the BBC still experimenting on the run-up to launching its television service?

John Logie Baird and the first television

John Logie Baird’s machinery transmitted live pictures by breaking them down into 30 lines made by a perforated disc spinning at high speed. By 1930, Baird was transmitting the first television programmes with the BBC. Synchronized sound and vision was broadcast to a handful of televisor owners and wireless enthusiasts who constructed their own spinning disc receivers.

Baird equipment

While these developments were groundbreaking, a clearer image—or ‘high definition’—would be needed for a full service and the BBC proposed a competition to find a solution.

The BBC’s television competition

The BBC decided that ‘high definition’ should be defined as 240 lines per image. They selected two companies to trial competing systems for the definitive solution to television: the Baird Company Ltd. and a consortium of Marconi-EMI. Each system used different technology and both were experimental, with no guarantee they could produce a reliable, high quality service. The BBC would trial each on consecutive weeks until a preferred system won.

With the competitors selected, a battleground was needed where the cutting-edge new studio facilities would be constructed.

Alexandra Palace is a Victorian entertainment complex on a hill in North London. Its high vantage point and pre-existing architecture allowed for a 220ft (67m) mast to be built on top of an 80ft (24m) tower of a building perched on top of a 306ft (93m) hill, providing maximum coverage across London.

Inside, former dining rooms were torn out and the two companies squeezed in their equipment, each managing to fit a fully equipped studio and vision transmitter in the allocated spaces while sharing transmitters for sound, dressing rooms and facilities.

Corner of a Victorian building with a metal tower structure being built on top Science Museum Group Collection
The BBC's aerial mast under construction on the east tower of Alexandra Palace, 1936

The Baird Company: Television on film

Ever the inventor, John Logie Baird had continued his experiments—moving into colour and 3D—while the Baird Company he had established sought new ways of delivering higher quality images.

The Baird studio had different types of camera system installed. The largest, for capturing the main performance, used an adapted film camera that recorded the images on film. The film was pulled through a hole in the camera base, instantly developed and fixed, then scanned for broadcast. The small camera shown below was attached to a large infrastructure of tanks filled with dangerous chemicals.

Vinten Model H 35mm film camera, believed to have been used with Baird Television’s system at Alexandra Palace, 1936

This setup was elaborate and difficult to use. The camera was fixed, so the whole programme could only be shot from one spot. If a bubble got caught in the developing tank it could interfere with the soundtrack, causing a loud ‘pop’ for viewers.

Small orchestra playing in a TV studio with lighting rig and a film camera on the left BBC Photo Archive
The Baird Studio in Alexandra Palace in August 1936, with the intermediate film scanner on the left

This ‘intermediate film technique’ camera captured the whole studio scene, so another solution was needed for close-ups. In a small ‘spotlight studio’ the presenter sat in complete darkness. In the neighbouring room a much larger and more dangerous evolution of Baird’s early equipment span a large disc fitted with glass lenses at high speed. It generated a beam of light that tracked across the presenter’s face through a window between the rooms. From the safety of their black box the presenters had to memorise their lines in pitch darkness; they were prompted to begin speaking by being prodded with a broom!

The time delay caused by developing the film meant action was broadcast 64 seconds late, while the presenters’ spotlight studio went out live. Coordination was difficult: in one studio the orchestra would have to start before an announcement had finished, and the next act had to be announced before the previous had finished.

Elizabeth Cowell sits against a light backdrop in a darkened studio, lit by a bright spotlight BBC Photo Archive
Television announcer Elizabeth Cowell in the spotlight studio, September 1936

Marconi-EMI: The ‘electric eye’

From the rival studio, Marconi-EMI avoided mechanical processes in favour of an all-electric system. From their labs in Hayes, the EMI teams had been working on a new form of television using a cathode ray tube—a glass vacuum where electrons could move from either end, creating an electrical signal for the image.

EMI had an agreement with the American company RCA which banned them from developing cameras using the technology and only permitted them to make television receivers. Two engineers—James McGee and William Tedham—experimented in secret, creating the first camera ‘eye’ tube in 1932.

Emitron tubes

Freed to continue work, Director of Research at EMI Sir Isaac Shoenberg oversaw a dream team of tech-nicians and engineers. Convinced by their ability to bring the invention to reality, he secured £100,000 from the EMI Board (a huge sum at the time) to create electric television. The result was the Emitron tube, the first electric camera tube to successfully transmit live pictures from the studio. By 1936 the cameras were ready for the competition, creating 405-line images—far above the 240 required.

The Emitron cameras were lightweight and free to move around the studio. Multiple cameras could provide different angles—though development was still needed to perfect them; cutting from one to another would send the signal out, destroying the picture. The ability to move the camera was a huge advantage—though before a special dolly was invented, the cameras were placed on an old Austin car chassis and pulled around.

Experimental broadcasts were made to a trade show, RadiOlympia, before the public launch. The programme Here’s Looking at You was devised by producer Cecil Madden and featured three stages separated by curtains, which the Emitron cameras would track through to reveal the next.

Marconi-EMI gallery

Baird goes electric

A coin toss decided that the system developed by Baird would present the opening broadcast on 2 November 1936. The television service would then be presented on each system on alternate weeks.

It quickly became clear that the Baird system was difficult. The Baird Company had a sharing agreement with the American inventor of electric television, Philo T Farnsworth, that allowed them to use his image dissector; the tube was inferior to the Emitron and required huge amounts of light.

Then, on 30 November, tragedy struck when the Crystal Palace in South London caught fire. The Baird Company’s own studios based there were destroyed, as was their back-up equipment. The smoke could be seen from the Alexandra Palace hilltop.

Melted image dissector tube by Philo T. Farnsworth, used by Baird, rescued from the remains of Crystal Palace in London following the fire on 30 November 1936
© Science Museum Group Collection More information about Melted Farnsworth Image Dissector Television Camera Tube
Photograph of the Crystal Palace fire, Sydenham, London, taken in November 1936 by Edward G. Malindine for the Daily Herald
© Science Museum Group Collection More information about Crystal Palace fire

The winners are decided

Within a few short months it was clear that the Emitron cameras developed by Marconi-EMI were the better system, and by February 1937 they were declared winners. They would go on to form the basis of television for decades.

Marconi-EMI continued to adapt and improve their Emitron cameras, and their system allowed for the first outside broadcasts and experiments with new forms of programming in the studio. But the early success of television would be cut short by the outbreak of war in 1939. When it relaunched in 1946 it was time for television to evolve again, with new innovations on the horizon.

Further reading

Online

Books

  • J.D. McGee, 'The Contribution of A.A. Campbell Swinton, F.R.S., to Television', in Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London Vol. 32, No. 1, 1977
Broadcast 100